When the SB Nation Reacts survey dropped this week, the results stunned even seasoned insiders: Mitch Keller, the Pittsburgh Pirates’ ace, topped the list as the most desired trade target among Chicago Cubs fans. Not Shohei Ohtani. Not Corbin Burnes. Not even Shane Bieber. Mitch Keller. The reaction? A mix of confusion, curiosity, and—above all—desperation.
Why Keller? Why now? And what does this say about the Cubs, their front office, and a fanbase that’s grown increasingly restless in the wake of unmet potential?
Let’s dive into what’s really going on behind this unexpected name dominating Chicago’s trade wish list—and why the clock may be ticking faster than anyone realizes.
The Cubs Are Running Out of Excuses
Coming into the 2025 season, the Cubs were a team with pieces. A solid rotation anchored by Justin Steele and Shota Imanaga. A lineup featuring the rising power of Christopher Morel, the consistency of Nico Hoerner, and the maturity of Dansby Swanson. On paper, they had what it took to compete in the NL Central.
But as the All-Star break passed, the team once again hovered around .500—neither contenders nor rebuilders, stuck in the purgatory of mediocrity. That, more than anything, explains the Mitch Keller fever.
Cubs fans are tired of “wait until next year.” They’re tired of watching their rivals make aggressive moves while their front office stays conservative. Keller represents not just a pitcher, but a pivot point—someone who could stabilize a shaky rotation and send a signal: We’re serious this time.
:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/26061328/ChicagoCubs_1_071525.png)
Mitch Keller: Ace or Mirage?
To understand the appeal, we have to look at Keller’s evolution.
Drafted in the second round by Pittsburgh in 2014, Keller was once viewed as the crown jewel of their farm system. But his early MLB career was rocky. From 2019 to 2021, he battled inconsistency, command issues, and an ERA north of 6.00.
Then something changed.
Over the last two seasons, Keller has quietly become one of the most reliable arms in the National League. His fastball has more bite, his cutter has become a weapon, and he’s shown durability, crossing the 180-inning mark while posting a sub-3.50 ERA.
He’s not flashy, but he’s efficient. He’s not overpowering, but he’s intelligent. And, most crucially, he’s under team control through 2026.
For a Cubs team trying to thread the needle between rebuilding and competing, that matters.
A Franchise Haunted by Missed Opportunities
What makes this moment more dramatic is what came before it.
Over the past five seasons, the Cubs have had multiple chances to make defining trades or signings—and passed. When the team sold off its 2016 core, including Kris Bryant, Anthony Rizzo, and Javier Báez, fans were told it was necessary to reset. And yet, here we are, years later, still waiting for that reset to turn into results.
Remember the 2022 trade deadline? The Cubs held onto Willson Contreras, despite knowing they wouldn’t extend him. Remember when they passed on Carlos Rodón, opting instead for “value” arms?
That pattern—of playing it safe, of half-measures—has worn thin. Mitch Keller has become a symbol of change. Of finally making a bold, targeted move instead of hesitating and hoping things break your way.
The Risk No One’s Talking About
But there’s a darker side to this desire.
Keller, for all his recent success, has never pitched in high-stakes postseason baseball. He’s also a workhorse on a losing team—how would he perform when every pitch matters?
The Pirates, fully aware of his value, aren’t going to let him go for cheap. The reported asking price is steep: think top prospects like Cade Horton or Kevin Alcántara, maybe even a package including MLB-ready talent.
Would Jed Hoyer and the Cubs’ front office be willing to pull that trigger? Would the fans still cheer if Keller comes to Wrigley but the farm system pays a heavy price?
In short: are Cubs fans truly ready for the cost of winning?
:no_upscale()/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/26061330/Screenshot_2025_07_19_at_7.54.27_AM.png)
Inside the Fanbase: What the Survey Didn’t Say
Beyond the stats and speculation, there’s an emotional element at play. Cubs fans have tasted glory, and that 2016 World Series win still glimmers in memory—but it also casts a long shadow. Since then, each passing year without meaningful October baseball feels like a betrayal.
The survey didn’t just reveal a name. It revealed a yearning.
A yearning for urgency. For ambition. For a front office that swings big. Keller isn’t the flashiest choice, but he represents something bigger: a moment to finally go all in.
What Happens Next?
With the trade deadline looming, the Cubs have a decision to make. Do they chase Keller with everything they’ve got, hoping he’s the missing piece? Or do they play it safe once more, watching from the sidelines as other teams make their playoff pushes?
Sources close to the Pirates suggest talks have happened—but no formal offer has been made. Time is running out.
For Cubs fans, the hope is simple: don’t let another opportunity slip through your fingers.
Whether Mitch Keller wears Cubbie blue by August or not, this moment will be remembered as a test of the team’s resolve—and whether they still believe in building something worth believing in.